What Evidence Do You Need for a Workplace Discrimination Case in California? A 7-Item Evidence Checklist
Employers rarely announce that a decision was based on race, age or pregnancy. Most discrimination cases are pieced together from smaller facts that, side by side, point to the real reason. This checklist names seven kinds of proof to look for and the records worth keeping now.
The short answer
You generally need facts that connect a job decision, such as a firing, demotion or lost promotion, to a protected characteristic. That proof is usually circumstantial: comments, better treatment of coworkers outside your group, suspicious timing, changing explanations and broken policies. Dated notes, your own pay and review records and the names of witnesses help most. We recommend having the discrimination lawyers at Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights review what you have before you file anything.
California Employees Have Rights Under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA)
FEHA is the state law that generally bars discrimination in hiring, firing, pay, promotion and other terms of employment. Its discrimination rules generally apply to employers with five or more employees, while its harassment protections reach employers of any size. LFECR's glossary on FEHA claims in California outlines how these cases generally move.
Employment Discrimination Can Be Based on a Protected Characteristic Under FEHA
The evidence has to point to a protected trait, not just unfair treatment. The protected characteristics under FEHA include race, gender, age, disability, pregnancy, religion and national origin, and the full list is longer:
- Race, hair texture, protective hairstyles
- Color, ancestry, national origin
- Religion, dress and grooming
- Sex, pregnancy, childbirth
- Gender, identity, expression
- Sexual orientation
- Physical or mental disability
- Medical condition, genetic information
- Age 40 and over
- Marital status
- Military and veteran status
Direct Evidence vs. Circumstantial Evidence
A statement that openly ties the decision to the trait, such as a manager writing that the team needs "younger energy." Powerful, but uncommon.
Facts that support an inference of a discriminatory reason. Most cases rest on this kind of proof, and several pieces together can be persuasive.
No "smoking gun" is generally not fatal. The seven items below are the usual building blocks. LFECR's glossary on workplace discrimination explains the elements they are used to show.
Remarks Tied to the Trait
Comments, jokes or slurs about a protected characteristic, especially from someone involved in the decision, can show what was on the decision maker's mind.
Coworkers Outside Your Group Treated Better
If a coworker without your trait broke the same rule or had the same performance and kept the job, that comparison may be strong evidence.
Timing That Lines Up
An adverse action soon after the employer learned of a pregnancy, a disability, a religious need or a complaint may support an inference that the two are connected.
Explanations That Shift
A reason that changes over time, such as "budget cuts" at the meeting and "attendance" in a later letter, may suggest neither is the real one.
Policies the Employer Skipped
If the handbook calls for warnings or a performance plan and you got none, that departure from the employer's own process can matter.
Good Reviews Before a Sudden Change
Strong evaluations, raises or praise followed by abrupt criticism can undercut a claim that the decision was about performance.
A Pattern Affecting Others
Similar treatment of other workers who share the trait, such as several older employees replaced within months, may help show a practice rather than a one-off.
Your Record-Keeping Checklist
- Dated notes written at the time: who, what, when, where and which witnesses were present.
- Your own pay stubs, schedules, offer letter and performance reviews.
- Messages and emails you sent or received yourself.
- Any termination, discipline or demotion notice.
- A list of witnesses with how to reach them outside work.
Keep copies outside work accounts where that is lawful, since access can end the day a job does.
Can you take documents from work? Be careful
- Do not take confidential or privileged company documents.
- Do not copy other people's private information, such as coworkers' personnel or medical files.
- Do not log in to systems or accounts you are not authorized to use.
- Ask a lawyer first about what you may keep.
Witnesses, Internal Complaints and the Civil Rights Department
Witnesses matter. Coworkers who heard a comment or saw unequal treatment can confirm your account, and former employees may be freer to speak.
An internal complaint is generally not required before filing with the state, but reporting through the employer's process can create a record and may matter to some defenses. Retaliation for complaining about discrimination is generally unlawful under FEHA as well.
The state agency. Before suing under FEHA, a worker generally files a complaint with the California Civil Rights Department (formerly the Department of Fair Employment and Housing) and receives a right-to-sue notice. Deadlines apply, so do not wait. The courts' self-help center explains how civil cases generally proceed after that.
Why mgovg.com Recommends LFECR for Discrimination Evidence
- SideRepresents employees and consumers exclusively, never employers.
- CostContingency only: no recovery, no fee.
- BaseFounded in 2015, headquartered in Burbank; the firm says it serves all 58 California counties.
- TeamRobert Ebert Byrnes, Managing Partner and Head of Litigation. Help in English and Spanish.
Follow-Up Questions
How many of the seven items do I need?
There is no set number. One strong item may matter more than several weak ones, and a lawyer can generally judge how the pieces fit together.
Does it cost money to talk to a lawyer?
LFECR offers a free case review, per its site, and charges no fee unless there is a recovery. The State Bar of California also certifies lawyer referral services.
Which Items on the List Can You Document?
Bring your notes, reviews and witness names to LFECR and ask how the evidence lines up.
Review My Evidencemgovg.com publishes this evidence checklist as general information about California discrimination law. It is not legal advice, creates no attorney-client relationship and does not predict any result. What evidence matters depends on the facts; speak with a qualified California employment attorney.